photohiker wrote:McGinnis wrote:I also have a couple of swags (semi-traditional and traditional), and they're super comfy but frustrating for long trips.
It would be good to hear your reasons for frustration

What type of swags do you have?
There are a couple of things about them that bug me. In the middle of the night, having to get up and go to the bathroom really sucks because you have to squirm to zip them down (losing warmth), then struggle to dress and put shoes on. This is also made worse by trying to do so without waking my partner when using the double (I think she likes swags more than I do). The second big one is when the sun rises and beats down on the canvas; because they're fairly confining, the heat from the canvas just radiates and bakes the inside of the swag. They're also not great in poor weather due to the shape. The AOS canvas is amazing, and water will pool without seeping through - until you unzip it and cop a face full of water.
It's also a pain having nowhere to store excess clothing, shoes, smelly socks etc. other than a drybag outside the swag.
Don't get me wrong, they're super comfortable, and incredibly warm even when it's freezing outside, but on trips longer than a night or two I take a tent. It's a love/hate relationship I suppose.
I've got three different swags (I have a shelter addiction):
1. An el cheapo Wild Country single dome swag (my first), that to this day is still comfortable, albeit useful only in fair weather unless a tarp is set up over it.
2. An AOS Adventurer double. Much, much hardier (14 oz Bradmill canvas which is tough as nails), and still very comfortable.
3. A Burke & Wills Ironbark (with full fly).
1 and 2 are dome swags, though the AOS is pretty close to traditional - nice and low, two poles; nothing like an Oztrail Mitchell or those hideous Darche swags. The Ironbark is a flat swag that I just tie off to a tree or the bull bar.
All three are comfortable, and great for a night or two, and I find myself using all three, but... caveat emptor.